DETAILS OF THE CHURCHES EXPLORED IN THIS BLOG
I) LIST OF CHURCHES
The blog will go through 234 churches established at various periods, out of which 23 are sites associated with the legends of St. Thomas, the Apostle (1st century A. D.); 148 churches are dated between 2nd and 16th centuries; and 63 churches are from 17th and 18th centuries. It must be noted that the chronologies of the churches listed below, especially the ones before the arrival of Portuguese in 1498 are mostly based on information gathered from local traditions as well as the data given in respective church souvenirs, diocesan directories, ecclesiastical records etc. It is quite intriguing how St. Thomas Christians assign such specific early dates purely based on traditional accounts, when archaeological or epigraphical data supporting these claims are sadly negligible to nil. Today, neither a pre-16th century church building survive in their original built-form nor a complete sample exists in Kerala. This should not strike you as particularly odd since most early churches were small, built of perishable materials like thatched palm leaves, straw, bamboo poles, wood etc., and they would not have lasted more than a few decades in the harsh monsoon weather conditions of Kerala. A significant proportion of the current church buildings are from mid- 20th century or later periods and they have been renovated or rebuilt several times since inception and are beyond recognition of their original form. Nevertheless, indigenous architectural elements and characteristics of the pre-Portuguese buildings are still retained in certain forms or patterns in a few surviving old churches. Unfortunately, given the popular trend among the parishioners to demolish old and unfashionable church buildings with massive and luxurious concrete structures with bold expressions, these old churches of traditional forms are also prone to significant alteration or total destruction.
Documented evidence and reports from early Portuguese period suggest around 100 churches existed at the time of the Synod of Udayamperoor/Diamper (1599) that can be classified as pre-Portuguese. However, when multiple foundation dates are reported for a church, it is generally safe to accept the later dates as the more reliable ones. Regarding the supposed first-century settlements, most of the sites shown today are relatively modern and meant to commemorate and symbolically represent events associated with the St. Thomas legends of the location. For instance, Azhikode (No: 1) and Kokkamangalam (No: 4) claim St. Thomas connection, but foundation of the earliest shrines on the site was laid only in the 20th century. On the other hand, churches in Palayur (No:2), North Paravur (No:3), Niranom (No:5), Thiruvithancode (No: 7) and Mylapore (No: 8 to 10) are older and definitely pre-Portuguese in origin. In certain cases, rival factions argue over who holds the ancient site and have churches close to each other, eg. South Paravur (No: 56 & 57), Chembu (No: 111 & 112), Punnathra (No: 174 & 175) etc. Similarly, when multiple churches at a location share identical establishment dates, the later dates are more acceptable, eg. Angamaly (No: 36, 41 & 41), Akaparambu (No: 38 & 39) etc. Take the case of Karakunnam twin churches (No: 92 & 120), the Catholic Church was established only in early 19th century and a 14th century date can be easily discarded.
The abbreviations used here mainly refer to the various denominations of St. Thomas Christians: SM, Syro Malabar; SO, Syrian Orthodox; LC, Latin Catholic; MT, Mar Thoma Church; MIC, Malabar Independent Church; KN-J, Knanaya Jacobite; KN-C, Knanaya Catholic; CSI, Church of South India; ASI, Archaeological Survey of India. The churches in Chennai are abbreviated RC (for Roman Catholic) and are shown separately since they do not belong the Syro-Malabar Catholic community of Kerala. The majority of indigenous churches (about 70%) discussed in this blog are currently owned by three main denominations of the Syrian Christians of Kerala, viz. the Syro-Malabar Catholic (107 Churches), the Jacobite Syrian Orthodox and the Malankara Orthodox Syrian Churches, the latter two are Oriental Orthodox sister churches and are classified under Syrian Orthodox (together they own 54 Churches). The LC churches (a total of 56 here, but the list is incomplete) in general are not pre-Portuguese (with rare exceptions) in origin and have hardly preserved any indigenous or Syrian Christian elements, but are still included since their foundation dates are pre-1800. The Knanaya communities (Catholic and Jacobite) do not consider themselves St. Thomas Christians but believe their ancestry to be from the Jewish Christians migrated from Middle East in the 4th Century A. D., and they own 7 historic pre-Portuguese churches. The church buildings belonging to Syro-Malankara (Catholic) and Church of East (Chaldean) denominations are not considered as they are 19th century or even later in origin. The post-synod of Diamper churches explored here are limited to the 17th and 18th centuries only. Interestingly, Tipu Sultan’s invasion coincides with late 18th century and has resulted in the destruction of many churches and the beginning of 19th century was a new phase with the emergence of novel Christian settlements and churches. Leaving aside a few architecturally important churches, I have not included structures whose foundation dates are from 1800 and afterwards. Most of the photographs were taken during my visit to the sites from 2015 to 2018.
THE COMPLETE LIST OF 234 CHURCHES-arranged chronologically based on the earliest traditional dates of establishment
No. |
Place |
District |
Name |
Date |
1 |
Azhikode, Kodungalloor |
Thrissur |
St. Thomas/Mar Thoma Pontifical Shrine (SM) |
1st C., 1953 |
2 |
Palayur |
Thrissur |
St. Thomas Forane Church (SM) |
1st C. |
3 |
North Paravur |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Forane Church, Kottakkavu (SM) |
1st C. |
4 |
Kokkamangalam/Kokkothamangalam |
Alappuzha |
St. Thomas Church (SM) |
1st C., 1900 |
5 |
Niranam |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Mary's Valiyapally (SO) |
1st C. |
6 |
Nilackal/Chayal |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Thomas Church (Ecumenical) |
1st C., 1983 |
7 |
Thiruvithamcode, Nagercoil |
Tamil Nadu |
St. Mary's Church or Thomayar Kovil Arapally (SO) |
1st C. |
8 |
Mylapore, Chennai |
Tamil Nadu |
St. Thomas/San Thome Basilica (RC) |
1st C., 1523 |
9 |
St Thomas Mount, Chennai |
Tamil Nadu |
St. Thomas Mount National Shrine & Our Lady of Expectation Church (RC) |
1st C., 1523 |
10 |
Little Mount, Chennai |
Tamil Nadu |
Shrine of Apostle St. Thomas & Our Lady of Good Health Church (RC) |
1st C., 1551 |
11 |
Raja Annamalaipuram, Chennai |
Tamil Nadu |
Descanso or Our Lady of Visitation Church |
1st C., 1650-1683 |
12 |
Piravom |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary's Piravom Valiyapally/Rajadhirajah (3 Kings) Church (SO) |
4th BC, 2nd C., 390, 9th Cent |
13 |
Arthat |
Thrissur |
St. Mary’s Orthodox Cathedral (SO) |
1st C., 999 |
14 |
Aruvithura (Erattupetta) |
Kottayam |
St. George Forane Church (SM) |
1st C., 151, 301 |
15 |
Cherpunkal |
Kottayam |
Mar Sleeva (Holy Cross) Forane Church (SM) |
1st C., 1096, 1111-12 |
16 |
Kothamangalam |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary/Martha Mariyam Cathedral Valiyapally (SO) |
1st C., 4th C., 498, 1240, 1340, 1343 |
17 |
Malayattoor |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas/Mar Thomma Kurishumudy Church (SM) |
1st C., 1595 |
18 |
Maliyankara |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Chapel (LC) |
1st C., 1953 |
19 |
Mathilakam |
Thrissur |
St. Joseph's Church (LC) |
1st C., 1767 |
20 |
Mylacombu |
Idukki |
St. Thomas Forane Church (SM) |
1st C., 600, 686 |
21 |
Mattel Thuruth |
Alappuzha |
St. Thomas Mattel Church (SM) |
1st C. |
22 |
Port Kollam, Pallithottam |
Kollam |
St. Mary/Our Lady of Purification Church (LC) |
1st C., 1329 |
23 |
Thuruthoor |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Church, Sinai Mount (LC) |
1st C., 1914 |
101-1499 |
||||
24 |
Kuravilangadu |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Forane (SM) |
105, 335, 345 |
25 |
Mattam/Mattom |
Thrissur |
St. Thomas Forane (SM) |
140, 480, 550, 900 |
26 |
Pallippuram-Cherthala |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary’s Forane (SM) |
290, 3rd C. |
27 |
Ambazhakad |
Thrissur |
St. Thomas Forane (SM) |
300 |
28 |
Chengannoor |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary's. Old Syrian Church (SO & MT) |
300, 1175 |
29 |
Kadambanad |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Thomas Orthodox Cathedral/Valiyapally (SO) |
325 |
30 |
Thevalakkara |
Kollam |
Mar Abo/Martha Mariam Church (SO) |
4th C., 9th C. |
31 |
Pazhanji |
Thrissur |
St. Mary's Church (SO) |
4th C., 1249, 1852 |
32 |
North Pudukad |
Thrissur |
Our Lady of Mount Carmel (SM) |
400 |
33 |
Parappukkara |
Thrissur |
St. John's Forane (SM) |
400 |
34 |
Puthenchira |
Thrissur |
St. Mary’s Thazhathapally (SM) |
400 |
35 |
Kaduthuruthy |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Forane Valiyapally (KN-C) |
400, 510, 1456, 1500 |
36 |
Angamali |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Jacobite Syrian Soonoro Cathedral (SO) |
409, 9th C. |
37 |
Kalloorkadu/Champakulam |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
427, 550 |
38 |
Akaparambu |
Ernakulam |
Mar Saabor Aphroth Church (SO) |
450, 825 |
39 |
Akaparambu |
Ernakulam |
Ss. Gervasis and Prothasis Church (SM) |
450, 1541 |
40 |
Angamali |
Ernakulam |
St. George Basilica (SM) |
450 |
41 |
Angamali |
Ernakulam |
St. Hormis Kizhekkepally (SM) |
480, 1540, 1585 |
42 |
Kuruppampady |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Jacobite Syrian Cathedral (SO) |
498, 1067, 1150, 1240, 1300, 1355 |
43 |
Kottoor, Kolencherry |
Ernakulam |
St. George Orthodox Syrian Church (SO) |
5th C., 9th C., 15th C. |
44 |
Paliakkara, Thiruvalla |
Pathanamthitta |
St. George Orthodox Church (O) |
5th C., 1814-1815 |
45 |
Enammavu |
Thrissur |
Our Lady of Mount Carmel (SM) |
500, 510 |
46 |
Edapally |
Ernakulam |
St. George Forane Church (SM) |
503, 593 |
47 |
Muttuchira |
Kottayam |
Holy Ghost Forane Church (SM) |
510, 550, 1400 |
48 |
Udayamperoor |
Ernakulam |
Ss. Gervasis & Prothasis/St Mary's/Synod of Diamper Old Church (SM) |
510 |
49 |
Chalakudy |
Thrissur |
St Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
600 |
50 |
Moozhikulam |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
601, 650, 691 |
51 |
Kolenchery |
Ernakulam |
Ss.Peter and Paul Church (SO) |
650, 1474-75 |
52 |
Thumpamon |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Mary's Orthodox Cathedral (SO) |
717 |
53 |
Karingachira |
Ernakulam |
St. George Jacobite Syrian Cathedral (SO) |
722 |
54 |
Kandanad |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary's Orthodox Church (SO) |
775 |
55 |
Thazhekkad-Avittathoor |
Thrissur |
St. Sebastian Church (SM) |
800 |
56 |
South Paravur |
Ernakulam |
St. John the Baptist Church (SO) |
802 |
57 |
South Paravur |
Ernakulam |
St. John the Baptist Church (SM) |
802 |
58 |
Manakodam, Thekke Thuravoor |
Alappuzha |
St. George Forane Church (LC) |
805, 1640 |
59 |
Kayamkulam |
Alappuzha |
Kadeesha Orthodox Cathedral (SO) |
824 |
60 |
Kothanalloor |
Kottayam |
Ss.Gervasis & Prothasis Forane Church (SM) |
826, 1220, 1320 |
61 |
Karthikapally |
Alappuzha |
St. Thomas Orthodox Cathedral (SO) |
829, 1240, 1581 |
62 |
Athirampuzha |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
835 |
63 |
Kundara |
Kollam |
St. Thomas Orthodox Valiyapally (SO) |
835 |
64 |
Kanjoor |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
863, 1001 |
65 |
Kadamattom |
Ernakulam |
St. George Syrian Orthodox Church (SO) |
865, 950 |
66 |
Pazhuvil |
Thrissur |
St. Antony's Forane Church (SM) |
883, 960 |
67 |
Kottayam |
Kottayam |
St. Mary's Valiyapally (KN-J) |
890, 1550 |
68 |
Kallada West |
Kollam |
St. Mary's Orthodox Valiyapally/Mar Anthrayos (SO) |
9th C. |
69 |
Mundenveli/Mundamveli |
Ernakulam |
St. Loius/Santiyago Church (LC) |
9th C. |
70 |
Arimpur |
Thrissur |
St. Antony's Church (SM) |
900 |
71 |
Malayattoor |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Church/Thazhathapally (SM) |
900 |
72 |
Nakapuzha |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s/Mother of Mercy Church (SM) |
900 |
73 |
Velayanad /Veliyanad |
Thrissur |
St. Mary's Old Church (SM) |
900 |
74 |
Pallikkara-Morakkala |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary's Jacobite Syrian Cathedral (SO) |
905 |
75 |
Manarcadu |
Kottayam |
St. Mary's Jacobite Syrian Cathedral (SO) |
910, 920 |
76 |
Mapranam |
Thrissur |
Holy Cross/Mar Sleeva Church (SM) |
928 |
77 |
Manjapra |
Ernakulam |
Holy Cross Forane Church (SM) |
943, 1401 |
78 |
Mavelikara |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary’s Orthodox Church/Puthiyakkavu Pally (SO) |
943, 964 |
79 |
Chennamkary West |
Alappuzha |
St. Joseph's Church (SM) |
977, 1801 |
80 |
Vadayar |
Kottayam |
Infant Jesus Church (SM) |
977, 997, 1001 |
81 |
Arakuzha |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
999 |
82 |
Kottekad |
Thrissur |
St. Mary’s Assumption Forane Church (SM) |
999 |
83 |
Nediyassala |
Idukki |
St. Mary’s Church (SM) |
999, 1400 |
84 |
Kadaplamattom |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Church (SM) |
10th C. |
85 |
Mattancherry |
Ernakulam |
Church of our Lady of Life (LC) |
10th C., 16th C. |
86 |
Kaduthuruthy |
Kottayam |
St. Mary's Thazhathapally (SM) |
1001, 1009 |
87 |
Vadakara |
Ernakulam |
St. John's Jacobite Syrian Church (SO) |
10th C., 1096 |
88 |
Pala |
Kottayam |
St. Thomas Cathedral (SM) |
1002 |
89 |
Bharananganam |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
1004, 1100 |
90 |
Muttam, Cherthala |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
1023 |
91 |
Chowara |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary's Church (SM) |
1025, 1100 |
92 |
Karakunnam |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary's Jacobite Syrian Cathedral (SO) |
1065, 14th C., 1792 |
93 |
Chendamangalam |
Ernakulam |
Holy Cross Church (SM) |
1075, 1201, 1577 |
94 |
Lourdupuram, Kanjiramkulam |
Thiruvananthapuram |
Our Lady of Lourdes (LC) |
1087, 1905, 1914 |
95 |
Kannamcode, Adoor |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Thomas Orthodox Cathedral (SO) |
1100 |
96 |
Mulanthuruthy |
Ernakulam |
Marthoman/St. Thomas Church (SO) |
1100, 1125, 1225, 1575 |
97 |
Ernakulam |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Cathedral/Our Lady of Ports/Thekkepally (SM) |
1112, 1175 |
98 |
Mammalassery |
Ernakulam |
Mar Michael Orthodox Church (SO) |
1113, 1159 |
99 |
Changanacherry |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Metropolitan Cathedral/Valiyapally (SM) |
1117, 1177 |
100 |
Edakochi |
Ernakulam |
St. Lawrence Church (SM) |
1119 |
101 |
Kudamaloor |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
1125, 1175, 1425, 1505 |
102 |
Vettikkal |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Dayara Chapel (SO) |
1125, 1200, 1815 |
103 |
Mulakulam |
Kottayam |
Mar Yuhanon Ihidoyo Orthodox Church (SO) |
1134, 16th C. |
104 |
Cheppadu |
Alappuzha |
St. George Orthodox Valiyapally (SO) |
1175 |
105 |
Thripunithara |
Ernakulam |
Nadamel St. Mary's Jacobite Syrian Church (SO) |
1175 |
106 |
Palluruthy |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary's Syrian Church (SM) |
1191 |
107 |
Chittatukkara |
Thrissur |
St. Sebastian's Church (SM) |
1200, 1770 |
108 |
Vaipur |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Mary's Pazhayapally (SM) |
1212 |
109 |
Alangad |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Church (SM) |
1300 |
110 |
North Kuthiathode |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Old Church (SM) |
1301 |
111 |
Chembu/Chempu |
Kottayam |
St. Thomas Jacobite Syrian Church (SO) |
1306-07, 1370 |
112 |
Chembu/Chempu |
Kottayam |
St. Thomas Church (SM) |
1306-07, 1370 |
113 |
Vaikkom |
Kottayam |
St. Joseph's Forane Church (SM) |
1309, 1391, 1809 |
114 |
Muthalakodam |
Idukki |
St. George Forane Church (SM) |
1312 |
115 |
Kallooppara |
Pathanamthitta |
S.t Mary's Orthodox Church (SO) |
1339 |
116 |
Njarackal |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary’s Church (SM) |
1341, 1451 |
117 |
Koratty |
Thrissur |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
1381 |
118 |
Poonjar |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Forane Church (SM) |
1381, 1542, 1600 |
119 |
Kovilthottam, Chavara |
Kollam |
St. Andrew's Church (LC) |
1398 |
120 |
Karakunnam |
Ernakulam |
BVM Rosary (St. Mary) Catholic Church (SM) |
14th C., 1817 |
121 |
Puthupally |
Kottayam |
St. George Orthodox Church (SO) |
14th C., 1557 |
122 |
Alappuzha |
Alappuzha |
Mar Sleeva Forane Church (SM) |
1400 |
123 |
Kottapady |
Thrissur |
St. Lazar's Church (SM) |
1400 |
124 |
Vallam, Chelamattom-Rayonpuram |
Ernakulam |
St. Theresa of Avila Forane Church (SM) |
1401 |
125 |
Thathampally |
Alappuzha |
St. Michael's Church (SM) |
1404, 1600 |
126 |
Purakkad |
Alappuzha |
Holy Cross Church (SM) |
1410, 1570 |
127 |
Maramon |
Pathanamthitta |
Mar Thoma/St Thomas Church (MT) |
1440 |
128 |
Kanjirappilly |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Pazhayapally or Akkarapally (SM) |
1450 |
129 |
Ramapuram |
Kottayam |
St. Augustine's Church (SM) |
1450, 1599 |
130 |
Kothamangalam |
Ernakulam |
Mar Thoma/St. Thomas Jacobite Syrian Cheriapally (SO) |
1451, 1455 |
131 |
Nechoor |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Jacobite Syrian Orthodox Church (SO) |
1455 |
132 |
Kudavechur |
Kottayam |
St. Mary’s Church/ Vechoor Church (SM) |
1463 |
133 |
North Paravur |
Ernakulam |
St. Thomas Jacobite Syrian Church (SO) |
1490, 1566 |
1500-1599 |
||||
134 |
Thumpoly |
Alappuzha |
St. Thomas Church (LC) |
1500, 1600 |
135 |
Valappad |
Thrissur |
St. Sebastian's Church (SM) |
1500 |
136 |
Burnassery, Kannur |
Kannur |
Holy Trinity Cathedral (LC) |
1501, 1792 |
137 |
Kothamangalam |
Ernakulam |
St. George's Cathedral (SM) |
1501, 1770 |
138 |
Saude, Mundamveli |
Ernakulam |
Church of Our Lady of Health (LC) |
1501 |
139 |
Kanjirakode, Kundara |
Kollam |
St. Antony's Forane Church (LC) |
1502 |
140 |
Fort Kochi |
Ernakulam |
St. Francis Assissi Church (CSI) |
1503 |
141 |
Pallipuram/Palliport |
Ernakulam |
Basilica of Our Lady of Snow/Manjumatha Church (SM) |
1503, 1507, 1602 |
142 |
Vypin-Ochanthuruth |
Ernakulam |
Cruz di Milagres Church/Kurishingal (LC) |
|
143 |
St Angelo Fort, Kannur |
Kannur |
St. James Chapel (ASI) |
1505 |
144 |
Fort Kochi |
Ernakulam |
Santa Cruz Cathedral Basilica (LC) |
1505 |
145 |
Tuet/Tuyyam |
Kollam |
St. Sebastian's Church (LC) |
1510, 1745 |
146 |
Kozhikode |
Kozhikode |
Mother of God Cathedral (LC) |
1513, 1599 |
147 |
Thirumullavaram |
Kollam |
St. John the Baptist Church (LC) |
1518 |
148 |
Kollam |
Kollam |
Kadeesa Syrian Orthodox /St. Thomas Church (SO) |
1519 |
148a |
Elanji |
Ernakulam |
Ss. Peter & Paul Forane Church (SM) |
1522 |
149 |
Vallarppadam |
Ernakulam |
Basilica of Our Lady of Ransom (LC) |
1524 |
150 |
Mayyanad, Kottiyam |
Kollam |
St. Jacob's Church (LC) |
1527 |
151 |
Thangasseri |
Kollam |
Infant Jesus Cathedral (LC) |
1529 |
152 |
Valiathura |
Thiruvananthapuram |
St. Antony’s Forane Church (LC) |
1530 |
153 |
Thuruthipuram |
Ernakulam |
St. Francis Assissi Church (LC) |
1531, 1533 |
154 |
Thankey, Kadakkarappally |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary's Forane Church (LC) |
1538, 1583 |
155 |
Maruthoorkulangara, Karunagapally |
Kollam |
Three Kings Church (LC) |
1548 |
156 |
Mattancherry |
Ernakulam |
Holy Cross/Bent Cross Church (SM) |
1550 |
157 |
Pulinkunnu |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary's Forane Church (SM) |
1557 |
158 |
Mampally, Anjengo |
Thiruvananthapuram |
Holy Spirit Church (LC) |
1568 |
159 |
Omallur, Manjanikkara |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Thomas Syrian Orthodox Valiyapally (SO) |
1573 |
160 |
Kottayam |
Kottayam |
St. Mary's Orthodox Syrian Church/Cheriyapally (SO) |
1575, 1579 |
161 |
Chungam |
Idukki |
St. Mary's Forane Church (KN-C) |
1579 |
162 |
Kallissery |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary's Knanaya Catholic Valiyapally (KN-C) |
1580 |
163 |
Kayamkulam |
Alappuzha |
St. Antony's Church (LC) |
1580 |
164 |
Neendakara |
Kollam |
St. Sebastian's Church (LC) |
1580 |
165 |
Arthunkal |
Alappuzha |
St. Andrew's Forane Basilica (LC) |
1581, 1584, 1590 |
166 |
Kattoor |
Alappuzha |
St. Michael's Forane Church (LC) |
1590 |
167 |
Koduvila |
Kollam |
St. Francis Xavier Church (LC) |
1598 |
168 |
Kozhencherry |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Thomas Mar Thoma Church (MT) |
1599 |
169 |
Venduruthy |
Ernakulam |
Ss. Peter & Paul Forane Church (SM) |
1599 |
170 |
Venmony |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary's Orthodox Valiyapally (SO) |
pre-1599 |
1600-1799 |
||||
171 |
Parassala |
Thiruvananthapuram |
St. Peter's Church (LC) |
1604 |
172 |
Vypin |
Ernakulam |
Church of Our Lady of Hope (LC) |
1605 |
173 |
Moothakara |
Kollam |
St. Peter's Church/Infant Jesus Shrine(LC) |
1610 |
174 |
Punnathura |
Kottayam |
St. Thomas Valiyapally/Pazhayapally (KN-C) |
1610, 1625, 1632, 1635 |
175 |
Punnathura |
Kottayam |
St. Thomas Vellappally (SM) |
1625, 1898 |
176 |
Arthat |
Thrissur |
Holy Cross Church (SM) |
1627 |
177 |
Painkulam/Paingalam |
Kottayam |
St. Mary's Church (SM) |
1627 |
178 |
Pullichira |
Kollam |
Church of Our Lady of Imaculate Conception (LC) |
1627, 1700 |
179 |
Uzhavoor |
Kottayam |
St. Stephen's Forane Church (KN-C) |
1631 |
180 |
Kadanad |
Kottayam |
St. Augustine's Forane Church (SM) |
1660 |
181 |
Pravithanam |
Kottayam |
St. Augustine Forane Church (SM) |
1660, 1714 |
182 |
Lalam |
Kottayam |
St. Mary's Church (SM) |
1661, 1663 |
183 |
Sampaloor, Palayamparambu |
Thrissur |
St. Francis Xavier Church (LC) |
1662 |
184 |
Kovilakathum Kadavu, Palliport |
Ernakulam |
St. Rockey's Church (LC) |
1664 |
185 |
Arinalloor |
Kollam |
St. George's Church (LC) |
1668 |
186 |
Chathiathu, Pachalam |
Ernakulam |
Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church (LC) |
1673 |
187 |
Varapuzha-Edampaadam |
Ernakulam |
Our Lady of Mount Carmel Church & St Joseph's Church (LC) |
1673 |
188 |
Kuttivattom Jn, Vadakkumthala, Karunagapally |
Kollam |
Three Kings Church (LC) |
1679 |
189 |
Kattoor-Edathiruthy |
Thrissur |
Our Lady of Carmel Forane Church (SM) |
1680, 1760 |
190 |
Eravipuram |
Kollam |
St. John the Baptist's Church (LC) |
1684 |
191 |
Rakkad |
Ernakulam |
St. Mary's Jacobite Syrian Cathedral (SO) |
1687 |
192 |
Chemmakkad |
Kollam |
St. Sebastian's Church (LC) |
1698 |
193 |
Mangad |
Kollam |
Holy Cross Church (LC) |
1700 |
194 |
Kandanad |
Ernakulam |
Infant Jesus Church (SM) |
1708, 1788 |
195 |
Pazhayangadi |
Thrissur |
St. Sebastian's Church (SM) |
1712 |
196 |
Velur |
Thrissur |
St. Francis Xavier's Forane Church (SM) |
1712 |
197 |
Kunnukurudy, Airapuram |
Ernakulam |
St. George Jacobite Syrian Church (SO) |
1715 |
198 |
Ollur |
Thrissur |
St. Antony's Forane Church (SM) |
1718 |
199 |
Kizhakkambalam |
Ernakulam |
St. Antony's Forane Church (SM) |
1725 |
200 |
Thalassery |
Kannur |
Holy Rosary Church (LC) |
1726 |
201 |
Parappur |
Thrissur |
St. John Nepumcian Forane Church (SM) |
1731 |
202 |
Puthenangady, Kottayam |
Kottayam |
St. Thomas Kurishupally (O) |
1731 |
203 |
Kalparambu |
Thrissur |
St. Mary's Forane Church (SM) |
1733 |
204 |
Mahe |
Mahe |
St. Theresa's Shrine (LC) |
1736 |
205 |
Perumanoor |
Ernakulam |
St. George's Church (LC) |
1742 |
206 |
Ranni |
Pathanamthitta |
St. Thomas Knanaya Jacobite Valiyapally (KN-J) |
1742 |
207 |
Kannamaly |
Ernakulam |
St. Antony's Church (LC) |
1745, 1873 |
208 |
Kunnamkulam (Chiralayam) |
Thrissur |
St. Sebastian's Church (SM) |
1747 |
209 |
Kunnamkulam (Chiralayam) |
Thrissur |
St. Lazarus Orthodox Syrian Church (SO) |
1751 |
210 |
Mattancherry |
Ernakulam |
St. George Orthodox Koonan Kurishupally/Erimegapally (SO) |
1751 |
211 |
Amaravila |
Thiruvananthapuram |
St. Antony's Church (LC) |
1755, 1775 |
212 |
Chathannoor |
Kollam |
St. George's Valiyapally/Martha Mariyam Suriyanipally (SO) |
1755 |
213 |
Vattayal |
Alappuzha |
St. Peter's Church (LC) |
1760 |
214 |
Kumarakom |
Kottayam |
St. John Nepumsyon's Church/Kariyil Palli/Vadakkumkara Palli (SM) |
1760, 1769 |
215 |
Kuruppampady |
Ernakulam |
Ss. Peter & Paul Church (SM) |
1763, 1767 |
216 |
Pudukkad |
Thrissur |
St. Antony's Forane Church (SM) |
1764 |
217 |
Thozhiyoor |
Thrissur |
St. George Malabar Independent Syrian Cathedral (MIC) |
1772 |
218 |
Alangad |
Ernakulam |
Infant Jesus Church/Kunnelpally (SM) |
1781 |
219 |
Mukkatukkara |
Thrissur |
St. George's Church (SM) |
1784 |
220 |
Kandachira (Kollam) |
Kollam |
St. Thomas Church (LC) |
1787 |
221 |
Meloor |
Thrissur |
St. Joseph's Church (SM) |
1788, 1865 |
222 |
Varapuzha |
Ernakulam |
St. George's Church/Puthenpally (SM) |
1788 |
223 |
Kunnamkulam (West Bazar) |
Thrissur |
St. Lazarus Orthodox Syrian Church /Pazhayapally (SO) |
1789 |
224 |
Vlathankara, Chenkal |
Thiruvananthapuram |
Church of Our Lady of Assumption (LC) |
1790 |
225 |
Thaikattussery/Thycattussery |
Alappuzha |
St. Antony's Church (SM) |
1791 |
226 |
Thirunalloor |
Alappuzha |
St. Joseph's Church (SM) |
1791, 1952 |
227 |
Pavukkara, Mannar |
Alappuzha |
St. Peter's Church (LC) |
1792 |
228 |
Thayyil |
Kannur |
St. Antony's Church (LC) |
1792 |
229 |
Vempuzha, Chingoli |
Alappuzha |
St. Thomas Church (LC) |
1792 |
230 |
Puthencavu |
Alappuzha |
St. Mary's Orthodox Cathedral (SO) |
1793 |
231 |
Thattarambalam, Valiyaperumpuzha |
Alappuzha |
St. Sebastian's Church (LC) |
1795 |
232 |
Aranattukara |
Thrissur |
St. Thomas Church (SM) |
1796 |
233 |
Kottamam |
Ernakulam |
St. Joseph's Church (SM) |
1779, 1799 |
The church at Elanji was
added to the list later when the photographs were already uploaded. Thus, it had
to be numbered 148a where it fits chronologically. This is done so that the
serial order of photographs remain unaffected. The total number of churches
therefore needs to be counted as 234. The photograph of Elanji church (148a)
is clubbed with that of Venmony (170). The above list is based on different documents including published books, parish directories, church souvenirs, journal articles, family records and various online resources. The data need not always be accurate especially in the case of online sources and family claims. However, as I have mentioned before, they are still included for giving an overall picture, but it is safer to accept the later dates. For instance, the churches at Lourdupuam (No. 94) and Thirunalloor (No. 226) are listed based on the earlier dates of their establishment, viz. 1087 and 1791, repectively. Although these dates are retrieved from the Catholic site, https://www.ucanews.com/, according to the corresponding church official versions, Lourdupuram was established in 1905 and Thirunalloor in 1952 only! Another example would be the Paliakkara church at Thiruvalla (No, 44) , the current church has a documented history from the early 19th century only, but according to a certain tradition (with no supporting evidence) Thiruvalla had a a Christian settlement in the 5th century! |
Claudius Buchanen visited r
ReplyDeleteRanuiel church on 12 Nov.1806.can you tell which is this church.
This church visited by Buchanan, also referred by him as located in the remotest parts, is the current Ranni, St. Thomas Valiapally.
ReplyDeleteAs per Historia Ecclesidie Malabarica ( 1745 ) written by Fr. J F Raulin in page no 428 and 429 clearly telles that 128 Mar Thoma Christian churches existed in Malabar before the arrival of Portuguese in .1498 and Kalparamb church has included in the list . India orenthalies Christiana (1794 ) written by Paulinies S Berthalomeia in page no 267 to 269 gives the list of Mar Thoma Christian churches existed in Malabar before the arrival of Portuguese in Malabar . Kalparamb Church has included in the list . Indian Church History 1818 London written by Thomas Years in page no 134 to 138 tells us the list of churches participated in Udayamperur Synod in 2599. Kalparamb church has included in list. Therefore it is very clear that Kalparamb Church has erected before the arrival of Portuguese in 1498 .
ReplyDeleteI don't think you can use any of these works to prove that Kalparambu has pre-Portuguese in origin. In this case, they can only be taken as secondary sources written approximately 250 to 300 years after the Portuguese arrival or 150 to 200 years after the Synod of Diamper (1599. Yeate's work (1818) has only a reproduction of Paulinus' list, so we can exclude that. You have skipped Du Perron's catalogue (1758) probably because Kalparambu is not in the list. The churches listed in these 3 works (Raulinus, Du Perron and Paulinus) are catalogued just as 'Ecclesiarum Christianorum S. Thomae' i.e 'St Thomas Christian churches' at the time of writing these works and not specifically churches before the arrival of Portuguese. Even if a pre-Portuguese origin is claimed, they are still from sources written 2-3 centuries after the Portuguese arrival. The closest we can get is Jornada which was written in 1603, just after the Synod of Diamper (1599). Most of the churches listed in Jornada are pre-Portuguese if we accept the fact that only after the Synod, the Portuguese had any proper control over the St Thomas Christian community and the churches they built. As I have mentioned in my blog, there are around 77 churches from Jornada that can be considered as of pre-Diamper origin, but Kalparambu is not in the list. The later 3 lists have several churches and oratories built after the Synod of Diamper and as you can see the total number increases with time: Raulin (1745)-128 nos; Du Perron (1758)-150 nos; and Paulinus (1794)-182. So it is not just Kalparambu, but several more churches you can identify in these lists, which however is not an evidence to prove that they are all pre-Portuguese. More importantly, the official church records and traditional accounts for the establishment of Kalparambu church is 1733 only!
ReplyDeleteFr. J. F Raulin clearly mentioned the name of Kalparamb Church as Kalparambil and Kalparamb Church has included in the list of 128 churches. Paulinies S Berthalomeia in his book "India orenthalies Christiana " written in 1794 clearly mentioned the name of Kalparamb church S.Maria in the list of 118 churches . Prof. George Menachery clearly telles us in his books that Kalparamb Church has erected before the Udayamperur Synod in 1599 . The Nazarany Sthambam in front of the Kalparamb church and available evidences got regarding Kalparamb Malpan residence and Kalparamb Seminary we can proudly to say that Kalparamb church has erected before the arrival of Portuguese in Malabar and before the Udayamperur Synod in 1599 .
DeleteI think you are confused with the primary and secondary sources. A primary source has to be from the time period being studied. I guess we can take before 1599 as pre-Portuguese here, since only after the Synod of Diamper, the Portuguese had any proper control over the Ecclesiastical life of St Thomas Christians. Now in this case, a document or report or an archaeological specimen from Kalparamb BEFORE 1599 is a primary source. A later date by a participant who witnessed an event at Kalparambu BEFORE 1599 can also be counted. So if a traveler visits Kalparamb BEFORE 1599 and he writes a memoir later, let say on 1610, it is still considered a primary source.
DeleteComing back to your comments, I am NOT AT ALL denying that Kalparamb church is clearly mentioned by Raulin and Paulinus in their church lists, nor that Kalparamb is Kalparambil. The issue here is that you are using the works published 146 years (Raulin) and 195 years (Paulinus) after the Synod of Diamper (1599), to prove the existence of Kalparambu church before 1599. My point is you CAN NOT take 18th century documents as primary proofs for the existence of pre-16th century church. This is not a specific problem with Kalparamb alone, but with almost all Syrian Christian churches of Kerala.
Similarly, a statement made in 21st century cannot be considered as the primary source evidence for a pre-16th century structure. Can you cite the source where Menachery is claiming that Kalparambu church existed before 1599. I would be more interested to know if he arrives this conclusion based on any primary documents or is it just his opinion or some oral traditions collected. The existence of Nasrani Sthambam (if you meant open air granite cross) is not an indication of pre-Portuguese origin of a church, as almost all the existing open-air granite crosses in Kerala today are of post-Portuguese origin! If however, the Nazrany Sthambam of Kalparambu is specifically dated pre-Portuguese with evidence (for instance an inscription on the cross?), it would be one of the rarest finds.
Regarding the seminary of Kalparambu, I understand there were two of them, 1) A seminary conducted in the premises of the church from 1807 to 1875; and 2) A Seminary started at Pukkot (Aripalam) only a mile west of Kalparamb in 1752, which was demolished during the expedition of Tippu Sultan in 1789/90. Would be happy to know if there was a third seminary at Kalparambu before 1599, again with the source details please!
If Kalparamb church is indeed of pre-1599 in origin, why is the official church site giving the date 1733 (https://irinjalakudadiocese.com/parish/kalparambu-st-marys-forane-church/) and this date has been repeated in several other records as well. Leaving aside the oral traditions and general speculations, it would be nice if we have stronger documentary evidence from the 16th century or earlier, to prove that Kalparamb church is pre-Portuguese in origin. To the best of my knowledge, the earliest available document where Kalparamb church appears is Raulin's list of churches in 1745. Let me know if you have come across any records before 1745 that mentions about Kalparamb church.
Hi ? Why are you giving importance to the list by Bernard Thoma of 1921? If he claims the list is from Jornada of 1604AD, he must not add churches into this list at his leisure.Also, why add the churches mentioned in Pius Malekandathil's introduction part. The introduction part written by him is not of guevea's book of Jornada.
ReplyDeleteWhat are these people's evidences of including other churches into the list.How can he prove they exist at the time of Diamper synod without any evidence?
Tradition or assumptions are not history. And Portugeese were available in Malankara from 1499 AD. There was ample time to show up in their records, nazrani churches. If you want the Jornada list of churches, why don't you read chapter wise? I am pretty sure the overall church count is below 40 only. And the other fact is that, the majority churches Menezis visited or mentioned by Guevea currently are held by the Puthenkoor faction. So the question arises - When was the parishes that syro malabar church/Pazhamkoor faction that claim to be old parishes were built. Were they built in the time period of 150 years after coonan cross revolt? Why there are no much churches mentioned in between Angamaly to Kunnamkulam eventhough the portugeese station was near. It was not that far interior, or was it? For the portugeese, the interior churches were in the south. But many churches are mentioned just when they took a roundabout journey through them. Why this paradox!
According to the publication law the J . F . Rauluans church history book in 1745 ,( Historia Eciesca Malabarecis) is only a translation of Jornado written by Gouva written 1606 . So definitely we can to assume that the mentioned church list in page number 428 and 429 are churches existed in Malabar before UADAYAMPERUR SYNOD IN 1599 . IT IS VERY CLEAR that Kalparamb church has included in the same. So we can definitely to say that Kalparamb church has erected before UADAYAMPERUR SYNOD IN 1599 .
ReplyDeleteIt must be noted that Antonio de Gouvea wrote his ‘Jornada’ (i.e. History of the Journeys of Menezes in Malabar) in 1603 in Portuguese language, and was published in 1606 at Coimbra (in Portugal), together with the 'Acts and Decrees of the Synod of Diamper' as one bound volume. Remember here that ‘Jornada’ and ‘Acts and Decrees of Diamper’ are not the same, but are two different yet related documents published originally in one volume. Now, when J F Raulin published ‘Historia Ecclesiae Malabarica’ (1745) in Latin, he included a translation of the 'Acts and Decrees of the Synod of Diamper' in his work, but NOT the ‘Jornada’. In other words, ‘Historia Ecclesiae Malabarica’ IS NOT A TRANSLATION OF GOUVEA’S JORNADA, but it does have the Latin translation of ‘Acts and Decrees of the Diamper’. In fact, the ‘Acts and Decrees of Diamper’ is a only a part (pp. 59-280) of Raulin’s 529-page volume. ‘Historia Ecclesiae Malabarica’ is therefore an independent work by J F Raulin, but to say that it is ONLY a translation of Jornada is not factually correct.
ReplyDeleteIf you go through the index of Raulin’s ‘Historia Ecclesiae Malabarica’, you will notice that it consists of 3 main sections-1) History of the Synod of Diamper; 2) Synod of Diamper (which is the 'Acts and Decrees of the Synod of Diamper') and 3) Dissertations. The church list which you are referring appears in the last section of this work (i.e. dissertations, pp. 428-429) under the title ‘Notitia Topographica Malabarica’. It is a compilation done by Raulin in 1745 and NOT A LIST OF CHURCHES THAT EXISTED BEFORE UDAYAMPEROOR SYNOD IN 1599. I hope you are aware that neither ‘Jornada’ nor the ‘Acts and Decrees of Diamper’ published in 1606 have a church list in it, so how do you expect one such list in a translation done in 1745.
I am a little surprised, why don’t you go through ‘Jornada’ itself when the full English translation by Pius Malekandathil (2003) is available easily for reference. If you don’t have one, try at LRC Book Stall, Mount St Thomas, Kakkanad, I am sure they still have copies for sale. This English version is essentially a word-to-word translation of the original Portuguese work of 1606 and it is heavily elaborated by footnotes. If you are so certain that Kalparambu is mentioned in Jornada, you should and must find it in the primary source itself rather than depending secondary or tertiary sources. Please let me know if you come with a reference to Kalparambu in Jornada. Best of luck!